Cookies 🍪

This site uses cookies that need consent.

Skip to content

Investors Overwhelmingly Tell the SEC to Keep Rule 14a-8

November 18, 2026

Opinion

by Andrew Collier, Senior Director of Freedom to Invest and Sarah Clark-Hamel, Director of the Investor Network at Ceres

For more than 80 years, Rule 14a-8 has given investors a simple, predictable way to raise concerns with the companies they own. Now the SEC wants to rescind it. 

The SEC's proposal hands control of the shareholder proposal process to the states – creating a 50-state patchwork of laws. In place of one federal standard, investors could face different rules, company by company and state by state, making engagement more contentious and costly for everyone involved. 

Shareholder proposals are non-binding 500-word requests used by investors to raise an issue or concern. They are often withdrawn once a company agrees to sit down and talk through the matter. For decades, they have helped standardize corporate risk management and governance practices across the market, from ensuring majority voting for directors, independent boards, and say-on-pay for executive compensation to improving transparency in political spending. 

That’s why a growing number of investors and investor organizations are pushing back. Pension funds, asset managers, and faith-based investors with hundreds of billions in combined assets have filed comment letters as of Wednesday, November 18, urging the SEC to keep the rule. Here's what they're saying, in their own words. 

Recission would silence the companies' actual owners 

Investors warn that rescission takes away a direct line of communication between shareholders and boards and leaves only blunt alternatives. 

"From a corporate governance perspective, preserving this mechanism is essential. Eliminating Rule 14a-8 would remove one of the most important tools available to shareholders for promoting transparency, accountability, and long-term value creation." 

"Dismantling this framework would not modernize our markets; it would diminish the voice of the actual owners of these companies." 

"One of the options left to investors to indicate displeasure will be withholding votes from nominees to the Board of Directors. However, this is a blunt tool that does not convey specific intent of the withhold vote. While investors can communicate with boards directly to explain withhold votes, the onus, and cost, is on the investor to do so. Without that communication, the signal sent to management is unclear and far less helpful than a vote on a specific item would be. It seems contrary to the SEC's mission of protecting investors to specifically remove an avenue of communication available to all investors." 

A patchwork of state rules means more cost and less certainty 

The SEC has framed rescission as simplification, but investors say it would do the opposite. 

"Rescinding the rule without a replacement would not simplify the system - it would result in a patchwork of state-level rules, increasing uncertainty and costs for investors and companies alike" 

"The existence of a consistent federal framework has informed our stewardship approach, engagement practices, proxy voting process, and governance expectations. Any rescission of the Rule would materially disrupt those established processes and increase uncertainty regarding how investors can exercise their ownership rights" 

"Rescinding will decentralize and lose uniformity of the process and standards of materiality by sending the proxy oversight to States. This is asking States to create capacity they do not already possess, and this fragmentation could create up to 50 different processes" 

Shareholder proposals provide a framework for dialogue 

For many investors, a shareholder proposal is valuable for the conversation it enables or continues. Without it, investors expect more litigation, public campaigns, and fights over directors’ votes. 

“Rule 14a-8 has played a critical role in supporting constructive engagement between companies and shareholders while providing an efficient and predictable framework for addressing material governance and sustainability issues. AP3 therefore believes that preserving this framework remains in the interests of investors, issuers, and the overall capital markets” 

"Rule 14a-8 is an established and efficient component of the US corporate governance framework. It gives eligible shareholders a proportionate, usually non-binding route to raise material matters, supports engagement before and after filing, and can resolve concerns without requiring more aggressive, binding, or costly escalation." 

Shareholder proposals surface material risks and opportunities  

Shareholder proposals often flag issues years before they show up in a company's financials, and many governance norms started this way. 

"For decades, the federal proxy process has been a vital, standardized mechanism for investors to raise material risks and hold corporate boards accountable. Many governance practices now widely accepted in the market began as shareholder proposals that gained support over time." 

"Shareholder proposals strengthen companies by surfacing risks and opportunities early. Shareholders who file proposals often identify emerging issues, such as workforce practices, supply chain resilience, and climate-related risk, before those issues fully register in a company's strategy or financial statements. A proposal gives the board a structured moment to examine the issue, weigh shareholder perspectives, and act while a risk is still manageable and before it becomes costly." 

The bottom line 

Whether they manage hundreds of billions or a hundred million and whether they're U.S. public pensions or Swedish national pension funds, investors are saying the same thing: Rule 14a-8 should be protected.

The SEC is accepting public comments through November 20. If you're an investor who relies on Rule 14a-8, now is the time to make your voice heard.